Basis of the Claim:

The Treaty 1 Agricultural Benefits Claim (the “Claim”), also know as “Cows and Ploughs”, relates to Canada’s failure to provide a variety of treaty agricultural benefits under the terms of Treaty 1. Pursuant to the terms of Treaty 1 (including the “Outside Promises”) the Crown was required to provide agricultural benefits such as agricultural tools, livestock, and seed. The Crown made this promise to support Brokenhead Ojibway Nation in establishing a thriving agricultural economy.

Current Status:

The Claim was filed with the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations on April 21, 2023. Pursuant to statute, the Crown must respond within the prescribed period. That period ends October 16, 2026. The Crown must advise BON tomorrow at the latest whether it will negotiate the Claim. If they do not give notice of their intention, BON may proceed to the Specific Claims Tribunal to adjudicate the matter.

To advance the Claim toward an efficient resolution, Chief and Council tabled a proposal to negotiate the resolution of the Claim using a similar Framework that resulted in the resolution of many Treaty 4, 5 and 6 Agricultural Benefits Claim under the Trudeau Government. BON’s Framework was developed with independent expert advice and tabled on October 2, 2026 with the Director General of the CIRNAC Specific Claims Branch, and his office has confirmed receipt of this proposal.

What happens next:

If Canada agrees to negotiate: The Proposal gives us a strong starting point for those negotiation discussions. Under the Specific Claims Tribunal Act (the “Act”), if negotiations do not produce an acceptable settlement agreement BON retains all legal rights.

If Canada declines to negotiate or does not respond: Under section 16(1) of the Act, either a written refusal from the Minister or without a decision communicated on or before October 16, 2026, BON will proceed to the Specific Claims Tribunal (the “Tribunal”).

Our lawyers have specialised expertise experience advancing Specific Claims to final resolution within Negotiations and at the Tribunal. Chief and Council are fully involved every step of the way.

About the Tribunal: The Tribunal is an independent body made up of superior court judges. It hears claims and decides both whether a claim is valid and what compensation is owed. The Act allows the Tribunal to accept oral history as evidence (s.13(1)(b)). It also prevents Canada from relying on the passage of time or delay to defeat the claim (s.19). The Tribunal can award monetary compensation up to a maximum of $150 million per claim (s.20(1)).

We will share Canada’s decision with membership as soon as we receive it.